John Henry Chugg and Catherine Gibbons Jones

This is the family I came to know most intimately, but still only through hearsay- or Family Lore- as this is the family of my own grandmother. Even in this there are things that elude me. I do not want blank boxes in my family records, however they are easier to accept for events centuries past. I shall continue to search.

John Henry Chugg (1850-1924)d Salt Lake City UT
sp Catherine Gibbons Jones (1849-1921) d. Ocean Park CA, m.1871 UT

.John Henry Chugg (1871) Twin, d Salt Lake City UT

. Annie Louisa Chugg (1871-1957) Twin, d. Los Angles CA
sp John Hughes Treharne (1869-1960)bd Salt Lake City, m. 1890 UT, div
..Howard J Treharne (1891-1902) d Salt Lake City UT
..Irene Annie Treharne (1893- ) d Probably Los Angeles area
sp Believed to be one Mr Waterhouse
..Pearl Alice Treharne (1896- )d Los Angeles CA
sp Richard Wright
sp Mr Lynch
..Mabel Catherine Treharne (1901-1983) d Los Angeles CA
..Melvin Wallace Treharne (1906-1986)Twin d. Pacific Pallisades CA
sp Nora Blanche Gibbons (1911-1986) d. Pacific Pallisades CA
..Douglas I Treharne (1906-1908) Twin d. Salt Lake City UT
..Raymond William Treharne (1911-1986) d. Van Nuys CA

.Dora Isabel Chugg (1873-1948) d. OK
sp Royal Jerald Kimball (1874-1916) d. Salt Lake City UT, m.1894 UT
..Royal Chugg Kimball (1894-1962) d. CA
sp Lucille Bright (1904-1981)
..Doris Kimball (1900-1976) d. Lockhaven PA
sp Benjamin Klusmeyer (1902-1973) d. Oklahoma City OK, m. abt 1923
..Kenneth H Kimball (1909-1915) d. Salt Lake City UT

. Edna Susannah Chugg (1875-1965) d. Salt Lake City UT
sp John Samuel Morris McCullough (1873-1964) d. Salt Lake City UT
..Leonard John McCullough (1897-1993)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Evelyn Ruby Lillie (1902-1992)d. Salt Lake City UT, m 1922 UT
..Derrell Willis McCullough (1901-1963)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Vannas Margaret Groo (1910-1993)d. Bountiful UT, m 1931 UT div
..Edna Grace McCullough (1906-2004)d. Ogden UT
sp Ralph Vernon Backman (1904-1992)d. Salt Lake City UT, m.1927 CA
.. Marion Louisa McCullough (1909-1996)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Guy Bertrum Brady (1911-1957)d. Salt Lake City UT, m.1929 div
sp John Bruner
..Helen Catherine McCullough (1912-1992)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Rudolph E Winter (1910-1979)d. Salt Lake City UT, m.1934
..Lloyd Blaine McCullough (1916-1991)d. Provo UT
..Robert Chugg McCullough (1920-1957)d. Billings MT
sp Shirley Seabury m.1940 div

.Willis Inego Chugg (1879-1948)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Sarah Jane Fletcher (1880-1925)d. Salt Lake City UT
..Catherine Chugg (1901) Twin d. Salt Lake City UT
..Eliza Chugg (1901) Twin d. Salt Lake City UT
.. Willis Glenn Chugg (1903-1963)d. Los Angeles CA
sp Puline Doherty (1904-1981)d. Anaheim CA, m. 1924 UT
..Raymond Edwin Chugg (1905-1991)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Norma Cook (1908-1996)d. Salt Lake City UT
..Ruth Chugg (1907-2002)d. CA
sp Arthur John Gudgell (1906-1979)d. WA

.Chloe Pearl Chugg (1880-1882)d. Salt Lake City UT

.Catherine Maude Chugg (1882-1964)d. Salt Lake City UT

.Ivor John Chugg (1883-1971)d. San Diego CA
sp Shirley Simmons (1886-1979)d. San Francisco CA
..Katherine Shirley Chugg
sp Harry Joseph Pike (1907-1974)d. San Francisco CA, md 1931
..Mildred Chugg (1912-1986)CA
sp Quitman Monroe Owens (1902-1935)d. NM, m.1931
..Richard Ivor Chugg
sp Geraldine Cave (1924-1995)d. Australia

.Alta May Chugg (1886-1961)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp Edwin Arthur Puzey (1878-1965)d. Salt Lake City UT, m.1908 UT
..Alta Catherine Puzey (1910-2000)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp George E Kemper (1915-1991)d. Salt Lake City, m. 1941 UT
..Afton Puzey (1917-2000)d. Salt Lake City UT
sp John Palmer Gleave (1915-1989)d. Salt Lake City UT, m.1941

The George Chugg Family

I know only data, it seems for George Chugg and his wife Mary Ann Thomas. They rest in the Ogden Cemetery but not very near John and Hannah Lee Chugg. Infants buried with them are John and Hannah's first children if I recall correctly ( I might have these infants confused with Moroni's first born and I will confirm one or the other for future articles.)
George and Mary Ann had twelve children, of whom only five married and four had families. George passed away nearly 73 years, Mary Ann eight years earlier at about age 60. George was a Railroad man as were some of his brothers, David the youngest being born in Wales died from an accident in RR work.

George William Chugg (1847-1920) d Salt Lake City UT
Mary Ann Thomas (1952-1912) d Salt Lake City UT; m. 1870 UT

.George William Chugg Jr (1871-1940) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Minnie Millard May (1872-1940) d Salt Lake City UT, m 1892 UT
..Wealthie May Chugg (1893-1978) d Costa Mesa CA
sp: Alvin Millard (1890-) m 1934
sp: John Kramer
..Ida Blanche Chugg (1895-1908) d Salt Lake City UT
..Alice Elsie Chugg (1897-1969) d Midvale UT
sp: Thomas Anton (1893- ) m 1918 UT
sp: Frank Hutchins ( -1967) m 1959 UT
..Alverda May Chugg (1899-1900) d Salt Lake City UT
..Berdine Hannah Chugg (1902-1985) d Los Angeles CA
sp: Dean Fred Kellenberger
..Mildred Grace Chugg (1903-1924) d Salt Lake City UT
..Marion May Chugg (1906-1950) d Santa Cruz CA
sp: Daniel P Doherty (1904- )m 1926
..Bernette May Chugg (1907) d Salt Lake City UT
..Georgette June Chugg (1907-1915)d Salt Lake City UT
..George Wesley Chugg (1909) d Salt Lake City UT
..Minnie Fay Chugg (1911-1988) d Sandy UT
sp: Alexander Clift Jamieson (1913-1987) d Sandy UT, m 1935
..Bertha May Chugg (1913- )
sp: Frank Allen Kerr (1913-1961) d Glendora CA, m 1937
sp: Joe Alex Lopez m 1965 CA
..Frank Fred Chugg (1915-1985)d St George UT
sp: Lavoy McInelly (1917-1976)d Hurricane UT, m 1937
..George William Chugg (1916-1942) d POW in Philippines during WWII. I believe remains are interred American Cemetery in Manila, a marker lies at the Chapel of Rememberence in Memory Grove, Salt Lake City.

.Annie Elizabeth Chugg (1873-1878) d Ogden UT

.Edith Louise Chugg (1874-1956)d Salt Lake City UT
sp Richard Rueben Worthen (1872-1947)d Salt Lake City UT, m 1899
..Richard Vaughn Worthen (1900-1959)
sp: Althea Virginia Evers (1903- )m 1922
..Kenneth George Worthen (1902-1976) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Maxine Rouech`e (1910-2003) d Salt Lake City UT m 1928
..Frank Waldo Worthen (1905-1971) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Esther Maude Butterwood (1908-1989) d Bountiful UT
..Reed Sherwood Worthen (1907-1974) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Evelyn R Nielsen (1910-1982) d Salt Lake City UT m 1938
..Edith Eileen Worthen (1909-1984) d Salt Lake City UT
sp:Albert Parley Neilson (1911-1972) d CA
..Glen Virgil Worthen (1910-1991) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Evelyn McCarthy (1914-1992) d Salt Lake City UT
..Lloyd Earl Worthen (1916-1995) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Cora Carter m 1942
sp: Jean B Barker (1920- )m 1950

.Frederick Chugg (1875) d Ogden UT

.David A Chugg (1876-1877)d Ogden UT

.Frank Ira Chugg (1878-1938) d San Francisco CA
sp: Ella Wilde (1882-1972) d Salt Lake City UT m 1901 UT
..Melvin Frank Chugg (1903-1984)d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Madolin Simpson (1907-2003) m 1924
..Dorothy Louise Chugg (1902-1995) d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Sheldon Theodore Capener (1907-1982) d Salt Lake City UT m 1926
..Harry Bennett Chugg (1919- )
sp: Elnora Nelson
..Paul Wilde Chugg (1915-1953) d Van Nuys CA

.Mary Florence Chugg (1880-1965)
sp: George F Borkman (1882-1948) m 1901 UT
..George Floyd Borkman (1902-1981)d Richmond CA
sp: Lula Barton (1905-1999) d Richmond CA
..Fern F Borkman
sp: Frank Anderson Smethurst m 1925
..Arthur Earl Borkman (1908-1966) d Farmington UT
..Grace Arlene Borkman (1908- )
sp: Ross B Strong m 1933

.Albert Edward Chugg (1882-1945) d Alameda CA
sp: Grace Homan (1884-1964) d CA

.Archibald Eugene Chugg (1884-1925)

.Son Chugg (1888) d Salt Lake City UT

.Bernee Raymond Chugg (1890-1919) d Los Angeles CA

.Elmer Earl Chugg (1894-1982) d San Francisco CA

Into the Next Generations: Eliza Chugg Butler Family

I see that I have not been consistent in earlier posts and so you may already be confused by the course I have taken. I have named Johanna's grandchildren, Generation Three. Next I will relate what I can of the generation Four and Five, giving dates only of those who are deceased. I will move as smoothly as I am able so better to allow you to trace the family you are most interested in- or so that you can track the other lines for your own curiosity about this remarkable family. Please, always feel free to contact me if you desire details on any of this report.

Eliza Chugg 1844-1890, died Butlerville, Salt Lake, Utah Territory
sp: Leander Butler 1842-1918, d Butlerville UT

Eliza Jane Butler 1865, d Butlerville UT

Leander Neri Butler 1866-1918, died Butlerville UT
sp: Sally Hepsabeth Wagstaff 1870-1947, d Salt Lake City UT
Eva May Butler 1894-1999, d North Logan UT
sp: Victor Eugene Israelsen 1894-1967, d North Logan UT
Gerald Leander Butler 1896-1944, d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Ella Ethel Birrell 1907-1994, d Murray UT
Merlin Alma Butler 1900-1970, d Murray UT
sp: Alice Elizabeth Berrett 1903-1976, d Murray UT
Clement Butler 1904-1995, d South Jordan UT
sp: Marion Echo Walker 1921-2007, d Draper UT
sp: Rose Malnar Wilkerson
Clella Butler 1904-1995, d Rochester NY
sp: Roy Schaedler 1902-
sp Harold Galvin
sp: John Anthony Barrella1900-1973 d Syracuse NY
Henry Lavere Butler 1908-1976, d Murray UT
sp: Vivienne Draper 1909-1997, d Murray UT

Edith Samantha Butler 1871-1936, d Murray UT
sp:Charles Franklin Boyce 1861-1929, d Salt Lake City UT
Charles Ivor Boyce 1891-1977, d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Eva Elizabeth Tuckfield 1894-1959, d Butlerville UT
Grace Eliza Boyce 1893-1945, d Murray UT
sp: Arthur Nelson 1891-1973, d Salt Lake City UT
Gladys Boyce 1894-1974, d Salt Lake City UT
sp: George Martin Blair 1892-1952, d Murray UT
William Boyce 1896-1896, d Butlerville UT
Alta May Boyce 1898-1980, d Salt Lake City UT
sp: Fred Amos Mosher 1887-1938, d Butlerville UT
Vera Elizabeth Boyce 1899-1990, d Spokane WA
sp:Joseph Mathias Rotzler 1896-1938, d CA
Perry Boyce 1901-1971, d Murray UT
sp:Lucy LaFern Winward 1902-1997, d Sandy UT
Leo Neal Boyce 1903-1972, d. Morgan UT
sp: Carma Perry 1910-1965
sp: Mildred Thornberg

Effie May Butler 1875-1904, d Teton ID
sp: Joseph Ira Staker 1870-1939, d Blackfoot ID
Alvin Ira Staker 1895, d Butlerville UT
Joseph Neri Staker 1896-1897, d Butlerville UT
Effie Nina Staker 1898-1925, d Idaho Falls ID
sp: Charles Conrad Miller 1897-1960, d Eugene OR
Vearl Clifford Staker 1900-1975, d Rexburg ID
sp: Rebecca Lyle Maupin 1906-2000, d Newdale ID
Veda Catherine Staker 1903-1981, d Ogden UT
sp: Leland Chester Cunningham 1900-1946, d ID

Alma John Butler 1879-1899, d Butlerville UT

Mary Elizabeth Butler 1881, d Butlerville UT

Sarah Pearl Butler 1886-1974, d Blackfoot ID
sp: Vincent Frederick Wootton 1881-1976, d Blackfoot ID
Ardella Pearl Wootton 1909-1963
Marlow Vincent Wootton 1911-1987, d Kirkland WA
sp: Viola Barnard 1919-2001, d Kirkland WA
Alta E Wootton 1916-1975, d Millbrae CA
sp: Donald Bennett McIlhenney 1912-1998, d Millbrae CA
Gaylen Neri Wootton 1920-1998, d ID
sp: Marilyn BoDean Butler
Wanda Lee Wootton 1923-1986, d American Falls ID
sp: Joseph Purnell Roberts 1916-1990, d American Falls ID

Stella Butler 1888-1968, d Blackfoot ID
sp:Antone Vernstine Hansen 1892-1987, d ID
Arvel Vern Hansen 1911-2003, d Rexburg ID
sp: Zella Evaline Gardner
Vella Stella Hansen 1914-2009, d Blackfoot ID
sp: Joseph Delos Mecham 1905-1984, d Shelley ID
sp: Brinkerhoff
Helen Pearl Hansen
sp: Weldon Adams Lewis 1921-1943, d Pocatello ID
sp: Dewey Duane Farmer
Donna Hansen
sp: Herbert Boyd Neider 1922-1998, d Pocatello ID
Clenna June Hansen
sp: Nathan Smith Plummer

Jane Eliza Butler 1890, d Butlerville UT

How To Proceed?

It becomes easy to lose track of the family lines if I introduce each generation separately. If I introduce each line as it comes up, for instance the line descending from John Chugg, will it be too long to get to the line from William?

My original research record was the long sheet and it went front-to-back from the parents through their family: Philip and Johanna, John, Eliza, Eliza Jane, Leander Neri, Eva May, etc with each individual numbered after the initials of the parents: John was PJ1, Betsy PJ1a, Eliza PJ1a1, Eliza Jane PJ1a11, Leander Neri PJ1a12, Eva May PJ1a121, which made some ease in locating a sheet in a book dedicated to that line. I do not think it would serve as well in this format. And I stopped numbering pages after I became dependent on electronic files!

John Chugg, married twice and having fourteen children, had ninety two grandchildren and two hundred seventy (or so) great grandchildren. Can you see the difficulty of using too many gadgets as the numbers, or keeping track of who was in the third or fourth generation and then if it should be the fourth generation beneath Johanna or John!

But I have these all in my PAF.5 file. I have been trying to identify and locate all the descendants of Johanna Stanbury Chugg. I continue to locate more when I do research, as I did last night with finding obituaries for Fern Borkman and Bill Fackenthall.

How shall I proceed? I am going to look at others' work and ask questions and give it thought. I want to relate the story of this family as fully as I am able and in a way that you can read and comprehend as well as use for your own research. Please return. Soon, I hope.

Johanna's Last Child, William's Children

William had children by his second and third wives, the first Mary Jeffries having died along the immigrant trail with out children. The children of Mary Mitchell, all born Providence, Cache, Utah:
Sylvia May Chugg, 1864-1934, married Alfred Brigham Crabtree of Providence. Their children were Alfred Brigham, Jr, 1885 - 1932, father of 6 with wife Enid Matthews.Russell William, 1887 - 1964, married first Bessie Poulsen, second marriage to Hazel Finch he was father to six children. Roland Myrle, 1890-1962, husband to Rachel Alder and father to six sons.Mable Rose, b/d 1896.Charles Milford,1902 - 1987, married to Norma Smith Campbell in 1926, having two children.
William John Chugg 1866 - 1939, married Bertha Zollinger of Providence. Parents of ten children: William Duard Chugg,1889-1941, married to Lillie Frederick and father of thirteen; Retta Irene C Matthews,1892-1994, wife of Newel Morris Matthews and mother of six; Gladys May C Hansen Smith,1895-1985, mother of ten children; Pearl Mitchell C Pickett,1897-1973, wife of Wade H and mother of four; Venna Bertha C Hammond Campbell,1900-1977, mother of three; LeRoy Edward Chugg, 1902-1987, married Laura Christensen and father of five; Melvin Zollinger Chugg,1904-1948, father of of four; Marion Byron Chugg,1907 - 1982,father of three; Erma Louise C Davis Smith,1909-1995, mother of one son; Mary Lenore Chugg, 1914-1915.
Mary Ann Chugg, 1868 to 1881; Jane Chugg, b/d 1871; Elizabeth Chugg, 1872 to 1874.
Parley Edward Chugg, born 1876 and married 1902 to Rosa Rindlsbacher. Died 1902, no children.
William's children by Eliza Barbara Frederick:
William Hyrum Chugg1881-1961, married Mary Josephine Rose, father of three.
Alvin Frederick Chugg 1882 to 1883
Ezra Albert Chugg, 1884 - 1965, married Lunnette Russon with 8 children
Nora Elizabeth Chugg Bisseger,1885-1969, married August Bisseger, mother of four
Nathaniel Benjamin Chugg1888-1942, husband of Hazel Smith, father of four
Mabel Eliza Chugg Busby, b.1896, married Bert Busby and had three children.

Third Generation, Ann Chugg Oliver Family

I have a record that shows nine grandchildren for Johanna by her daughter Ann. Ann married John Oliver in Cardiff in 1857. Her first two chidren died at birth or in infancy, three others I can locate no information other than birth dates. All were born St John Baptist Parrish, Cardiff, Wales.
Jane Oliver, born and died 1858
Eliza Anna Oliver, born and died 1860
Sarah Jane Oliver, born 1861
John William Oliver, born 1862 and married 1882 Catherine Williams, having four daughters: Mary, Lillian, Maggie, Catherine.
Mary Elizabeth Oliver, born 1864
Ellen Martha Oliver, born 1866 and marrying Frank Haines 1884, having three sons and a daughter: John Henry, Frank, Annie, William O.
Amelia Oliver, born 1867, married 1886 to William James Lindsay, being parents to eleven children: Walter John, Beatrice, Ethel Maud, William Oliver, Gladys Emma, Albert Stanley, James Alfred, Oliver George, Edward Oliver, George Leslie, and Arthur Niman.
Eliza Ann Oliver, born 1869
Thomas Henry Oliver,born 1871 and with wife Margaret having two daughters: Florence and Gwendoline.

Grandchildren Through Mary and Catherine

Mary Chugg married George Lane in 1850, I have a record of one child, Thomas Lane for whom I have not gained further information. Writing this story has provided some encouragement to research the Lane family again, which I have foregone as I focused on the American pioneer families. A note on the Message Board at www.ancestry.com some years ago reminded me that there are kin yet in England and Wales.

Through Catherine there are these grandchildren. I have found variant spellings, selecting this spelling here and throughout my personal records:
John Chappelle, 1853 to 1872 and Thomas Chappelle, b. 1854
Mary Jane Chappelle Bradder, 1856 to 1924 born Cardiff and passed in Lehi, Utah. Arthur Bradder was a stonemason, carving headstones and in Lehi an obolisk that stands outside the Lehi historical center. Of thirteen children I have for this couple there are several buried in the Ogden City Cemetery that have no marker, I attribute this to the hardships of pioneering, there could be no stone "extra" that they could have used. I cannot confirm this, perhaps I am off the mark. Four daughters lived to have families of their own: Alice B de St Jeor, Henrietta B Gill, Jane B de St Jeor and Mabel B de St Jeor. The de St Jeor husbands were two brothers and a cousin. All these families settled in Lehi or other Utah County locations.
Elizabeth Ann Chappelle Madden, b. 1858, no further record. in my files and one unnamed daughter b/d 1860.
William Chappelle 1862 to 1922, born Cardiff and living his life out in Ogden, Utah. He married Fidelia Lowe in 1881 and they were parents to six sons, William Andrew, John Arthur, Thomas Alonzo, Walter Webb, Clarence August and Henry Rodger; all living to adulthood. Fidelia passed away 1938, and rests beside her husband in the Ogden City Cem.